Proseminar
Religion & Politics in Modern America
History J495 - Section C696
Fall 2000, Thursdays, 5:45p.m. - 8:25p.m.
Cavanaugh Hall 537
| Instructor: Dr. Nancy M. Robertson | Office: Cavanaugh Hall 504N |
| Office Hours: Tuesdays, 4:00-5:00 | phone/voice mail: 317/274-8017 |
| Thursdays, 1:00-2:00, or by appt. | e-mail address: nmrobert@iupui.edu |
Course Description:
This course examines the interplay between religion and politics in recent American history. Despite (or perhaps, because of) the fact that etiquette books historically advised against discussing either of these topics in social settings, there is a growing, exciting historical literature that focuses on the topic as a way of understanding the larger social context and the forces transforming American life. In particular, the course focuses on the analyses of
AProtestantism@ as the national religion of the United States.In addition to addressing the specific topic, the course will emphasize questions of what history is, why we write history, and who historians are. After examining the theme of religion and politics in four pivotal moments in American history, students will develop, research, and write their own project. In addition, as part of being historians, students will exchange work with classmates as part of a peer-review process.
Although there will be some lecture to provide background, classes will primarily be discussion. You should come prepared to talk about the issues raised by the readings, your research, you and your colleagues
= projects, and lectures.
Course Objectives:
The sustained research project produced by each student will demonstrate his or her ability:
to select an historical topic, identify its significance, and make a plan of research for that topic;
to identify and locate primary (first-hand) sources concerning the topic you have chosen;
to identify significant secondary literature regarding that topic, and trace the historiography of that topic;
to present a thesis, based on research in both secondary and primary literature and sources;
to defend that thesis and make a clear and cogent argument in its defense.
In addition, the peer paper critique, will demonstrate the student
=s abilityto constructively assist a colleague in improving their work
Required Books:
These can be purchased at the bookstore in Cavanaugh or at Folletts..
Randall Balmer, Mine Eyes Have Seen the Glory: a journey into the evangelical subculture in America, exp. paperback (New York: Oxford, 1993).
Paul E. Johnson and Sean Wilentz, The Kingdom of Matthias: a story of sex and salvation in 19th-century America (New York: Oxford, 1994).
Katharine Du Pre Lumpkin, The Making of a Southerner (University of Georgia Press, 1992).
Optional Books:
The following have also been ordered by Cavanaugh and Folletts.
Edwin Scott Gaustad, A Religious History of America, new revised edition (New York: Harper Collins, 1990)
Kate L. Turabian, A Manual for Writers of Term Papers, Theses, and Dissertations, 6th edition (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996)
I also recommend having access to a Bible or appropriate sacred text.
On Reserve in Library:
I will post a list on ONCOURSE of books on Reserve in the Library.
Other Resources:
I will assemble web sites as I find them, but one place to start is the Listserv for American Religious History at:
http://www2.h-net.msu.edu/~amrel/
Course Requirements:
Class Participation (35% of final grade)
Completion of reading by the assigned date, attendance at class meetings, oral presentation of one=s work, and participation in class discussions. By definition a seminar requires a give and take that can happen only when people are there and participate. Please note that participation means not just speaking. It means being prepared and contributing thoughtful ideas or opinions.
Annotated Research Prospectus (5%)
This is a 2 to 3 page outline, plus annotated bibliography of the proposed research paper and contains the following:
B
outline of general thesis and proposed organization of the paper
B
an annotated bibliography that provides a capsule summary of the content and usefulness of the main primary sources to be used in the paperB
a list of, and annotations for at least 6 secondary sources relevant to the topic (in addition to class readings)This is due October 5th and is MANDATORY. I will not accept a paper if I did not clear the prospectus in advance
Peer Critique (10%)
This is a 2 to 3 page written critique of another student=s first draft. Detailed instructions will be provided in-class, but the overall purpose is to assist the other student in writing a stronger paper (and to receive the same assistance yourself). It is due the night of their presentation.
Research Paper (50% for final draft)
This is a 20 to 25 page paper based primarily on primary and secondary sources. This paper is the culmination of your course work, prospectus, and peer critique. It is your chance to write an original academic paper. Details for proceeding will be provided in class and during one-on-one meetings. The paper should be submitted in a completed (not Arough@) draft form, critiqued, and then returns for further polishing.
Grading policies:
While the majority of your grade will be based on your written work, active, constructive class participation is essential to a successful class. Attendance will be taken and unexcused absences will affect the participation grade accordingly.
Developing your intellectual skills is possible only when you actually do the work assigned. We will have a longer discussion of intellectual work, intellectual dishonesty, and plagiarism. Plagiarism and cheating will result in an
AF@ for the work in question and possible disciplinary action by the University. See the Indiana University Academic Handbook (p. 123) or the IUPUI Campus Bulletin, 2000-2002 (p. 36) or talk with me if you have questions about what is or is not permissible.A grade of
Aincomplete@ is troublesome for everyone. The University=s policy is that they are only for students who have completed almost all course requirements and have been prevented by significant or unanticipated circumstances from finishing them.Logistics:
As you may know, you are entitled to an e-mail account through IUPUI. I realize that many of you prefer to use another provider for e-mail and web work. The University encourages you to set up your IUPUI account to forward information to your other accounts. It means that you can easily access information from the University. It also assists me if I need to send out a general class announcement, although these will normally be on ONCOURSE. If you need help setting up the account or forwarding mail, contact:
http://iupui-accts.iupui.edu/students/student.html
FYI: There is a University web page that will let you know if the campus is closed for snow:
http://www.iupui.edu/it/registrar/adverseweather.html
THREE IMPORTANT POINTS:
The syllabus for this course will be on ONCOURSE. I will post additions, corrections, handouts, and other supplemental materials there as well announce them in class. It is the responsibility of the student to stay on top of changes.
I cannot stress too heavily the usefulness of planning ahead, saving work on your computer OFTEN, making backups, and printing out your paper early.
Books, handouts, and other reading material should be brought to class the day/s they are being discussed.
TENTATIVE COURSE OUTLINE AND ASSIGNMENTS |
||
| 8/25: | Introductions, overview of course objectives, requirements, themes, and the syllabus. | |
| Handout: Brecht: AA Worker Reads History@ | ||
| 8/31: | WHAT IS HISTORY, WHO ARE HISTORIANS, WHY DO WE WRITE HISTORY? | |
History=s great tradition is to help us understand ourselves and our world so that each of us, individually and in conjunction with our fellow men, can formulate relevant and reasoned alternatives and become meaningful actors in making history. Considered in this light, History is a way of learning. -William Appleman Williams |
||
| Carl Becker, AEveryman His Own History@ AHR (1932) - J-STOR. | ||
| Florence Miller, AOpen Letter to Salman Rushdie@ (1992) - ERROL. | ||
| FOUNDING DOCUMENTS AND BACKGROUND | ||
Protestantism is America=s Aonly national religion and to ignore that fact is to view the country from a false angle.@ Andre Siegfried, 1927 |
||
| John Winthrop, AA Model of Christian Charity@ - ERROL. | ||
| ADeclaration of Independence@ - ERROL. | ||
| AConstitution@ Preamble, Article VI, and the First Amendment - ERROL. | ||
| Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America: v. 1: pp. 310-26 and v. 2: 21-29, 114B18, | ||
| 123-28, 133-35, 152-56 - ERROL. | ||
| William McLoughlin, AEnthusiasm for Liberty@ - ERROL. | ||
| Bring in an article which reveals some aspect of the intersection of religion and politics | ||
WHAT IS NEW AND WHAT IS TRADITIONAL? 1830s-1860s |
||
| 9/7: | Johnson and Wilentz, The Kingdom of Matthias - ALL | |
| PARAGRAPH PROPOSING TOPIC DUE | ||
| 9/14: | Religion and women; God and politics | |
| Ruth H. Bloch, AAmerican Feminine Ideals in Transition@ (1978) - ERROL. | ||
| Nell Painter, ARepresenting Truth@(1994) - J-STOR. | ||
| Abraham Lincoln, TBA - ERROL. | ||
| MATERNALISM AND MASCULINITIES 1890s-1920 | ||
| 9/21: | Gail Bederman, AThe Women Have Had Charge of the Church Work Long Enough@ American Quarterly (1989) J-STOR. | |
| Susan Curtis, "The Son of Man and God the Father@ - ERROL. | ||
| Herbert G. Gutman, AProtestantism and the American Labor Movement@ AHR (1966) J-STOR | ||
| Joan Jacobs Brumberg, AZenanas and Girlless Villages@ JAH (1982) J-STOR. | ||
| PROGRESS REPORT ON TOPIC | ||
| 9/28: | No class; work on Prospectus | |
| RELIGION: A PROGRESSIVE or CONSERVATIVE FORCE? 1920s-1980s | ||
| 10/5: | ANNOTATED PROSPECTUS DUE | |
| Lumpkin, Making of a Southerner | ||
| Martin Luther King, documents - ERROL. | ||
| 10/12: | Balmer, Mine Eyes Have Seen the Glory | |
| 10/19: | Christian Coalition and the New Right | |
| Jerry Falwell, "The Imperative of Moral Involvement,@ - ERROL. | ||
| BRIEF PROGRESS REPORTS | ||
| Discuss citation style, footnotes, and bibliography | ||
| 10/26: | No Class - Research | |
| 11/2: | No Class - Research | |
| 11/9: | FIRST DRAFTS DUE: Drop off your paper and pick up papers to critique | |
| 11/14 | 5 p.m.: last day to withdraw Fall 2000 courses. | |
| 11/16: | Presentations 1-4 (10-15 minute from the presenter, followed by respondent for 5-10 minutes) | |
| 11/23: | NO CLASS - Thanksgiving | |
| 11/30: | Presentations 5-8 | |
| 12/7: | Presentations 9-12 and wrap up | |
| Conclusion and evaluation | ||
| 12/14: | FINAL PAPERS DUE by 5:30 p.m. | |